Lindsay’s police chief welcomes basic income pilot to community

Lindsay’s police chief welcomes basic income pilot to community
City of Kawartha Lakes Police Chief, John Hagarty.

As the town of Lindsay prepares for its basic income pilot to begin this fall, its police chief is already on board.

City of Kawartha Lakes Police Chief, John Hagarty, says he’s pleased the town has been chosen as one of three centres in Ontario for the pilot. He’s especially happy that about a full 10 percent of the community could be participants in the program.

Out of the 4,000 participants, who will be invited to participate, 1,000 will be from the Hamilton/Brantford area and another 1,000 will be from Thunder Bay. However, 2,000 participants will be invited from Lindsay, making it a vital part of the pilot to test behaviours, work patterns, health and mental health outcomes, housing stability, educational attainment, and how the community as a whole may benefit.

Given Lindsay’s population is about 20,000, this represents about 10 percent of the population.

Hagarty says he understands “how it will benefit members of our community, particularly allowing them more flexibility to earn an income.”

Eligible participants in the pilot program will receive:

  • Up to $16,989 per year for a single person, less 50 percent of any earned income
  • Up to $24,027 per year for a couple, less 50 percent of any earned income
  • Up to an additional $6,000 per year for a person with a disability.

Chief Hagarty says although he supports the pilot he believes the 50 percent reduction “is too high.” He thinks people should be able to keep more of the additional monies they earn.

Hagarty says he believes basic income will help make the system more efficient, “but more importantly it provides encouragement to seek additional income through employment.”

“And in doing that, (it) will give them a chance to get out of poverty,” Hagarty adds, ideally breaking the cycle.

The chief says that from a crime perspective, he believes people who live in poverty “are more likely to become victims of crime than criminals.”

“Eliminating or reducing poverty will reduce victimization.”

Ontario’s basic income plan will target a mix of people for the program, such as those who are working but not working enough to stay out of poverty, those who are currently on social assistance, and homeless people.

Cathedral Thinking

The police chief is a believer in ‘cathedral thinking,’ a term referring to medieval times when stonemasons and architects had to plan across a generation or more to get something as grand as a cathedral built. He says this notion that it takes a shared commitment to long-term implementation and results reminds him of applying the same mentality for implementing basic income.

“What are some actions that I could take today that could take 20 to 25 years or more before we would see a benefit?” he asks. He believes basic income is a program like this, given its ‘upstream’ benefits.

“One of the problems we face as a society is that we often need to see almost immediate benefits,” he notes. This could be because of a political party’s tenure, or because of municipal budgets, all affecting decision making before approving an action.

“I think, in our various roles, we need to think further out and take a leap of faith when we believe in what the expected results will be, even if we may not see the benefit,” Hagarty says.